Your Best Drugstore Nail Polish?

We have our list of professional polish brands, but how about we do the opposite? What are the best drugstore nail polish brands out there?

25 Likes

If we’re talking drugstore picks, this should be on your list.

No UV lamp needed, so it’s somewhere between regular polish and salon gel. The flat brush helps it go on more evenly than a lot of cheaper polishes, and it dries fast once the top coat is on.

3 Likes

Since this thread is the flip side of the pro list, I’d say this one… even if it’s kind of borderline.

Most drugstores carry it but it’s better quality than some of the cheaper bottles. There are also tons of color choices to this one.

5 Likes

Revlon Lustrous is my pick from the drugstore, especially the classic reds and darker cremes. The formula levels out nicely and the brush makes it easy to stay clean around the cuticle. Two thin coats plus top coat lasts me about 5 days before the tips start to wear.

The pale shades need 3 coats, so I skip those. The deeper colors are opaque in two. Removal is easy too, no staining.

Some of these cheap formulas last longer than stuff triple the price.

Sally Hansen Insta-Dri is what I use most. It dries fast enough that I can touch things within 10 minutes without wrecking everything. Essie’s brush is nicer and the color range is huge, but the formula can get streaky depending on the shade. Wet n Wild Mega Last is the best value at like 3 bucks a bottle (more on that here). I keep eyeing the L’Oreal ones and never buying them. Anyone tried those?

4 Likes

Rimmel London 60 Seconds is my best drugstore polish. I use it when I want something that holds up next to the pro gel brands but still lets me switch colors. 2 coats are enough.

The grays and greens stay rich, and the wide flat brush keeps the edges clean. I do add a clear top coat though, because without it the shine drops off by day three. Walgreens usually has a decent shade selection.

Same experience with the darker cremes. Two thin coats and they level fine.

The pale shades dry slower for me and tend to pull at the first coat unless I wait longer between layers.

The shine dropping off by day 3 is so real. I like the 60 Seconds formula for how fast it sets and how good the darker shades look, but it goes dull faster than almost anything else I own.

What’s worked for me is adding a thin layer of clear the next morning, and that keeps the gloss going closer to a week. Does the extra top coat mess with the dry time for you at all?

5 Likes

Probably the extra bulk.

Do you use a quick-dry top coat or whatever clear you have around?

1 Like

A little, but waiting until the next morning helps. I use one thin layer of quick-dry clear, and it’s usually touch-dry in about 15 minutes. I still give it a little longer before washing dishes or digging through my bag, since that’s when I manage to dent it.

I use a quick-dry top coat rather than whatever clear polish is nearby. A regular clear stays tacky longer, and adding it over 2 coats of color can make the whole thing feel thick. I keep the next-morning coat thin and cap the tips. If I’m in a rush, I skip it and accept that the Rimmel will look a little dull by day three.

The brush on these is perfect though. Wide and flat, it lays down color exactly where you want it.

I ignored them forever because the ‘gel’ marketing made me think I needed a lamp. The bottles are bulky as hell in storage. But that brush is why I keep buying them.

Sally Hansen Miracle Gels come in clear bottles because they’re regular nail polish, not actual gel. Real gel polish needs UV light to cure, so it would get ruined by light exposure in a clear bottle.

The ‘gel-like’ part is marketing speak for a lacquer that’s supposed to last longer than normal polish.

Once your technique is solid and you’re using a base and top coat, any drugstore polish holds up well. The big brands have nicer brushes, which saves time. The cheap ones work fine too if you don’t mind a little extra effort.

Sally Hansen Insta-Dri works for me. Lasts a decent while, too.

But I end up walking away from a lot of their other lines because the shade range feels pretty basic.

I keep seeing conflicting info about whether this brand needs a UV lamp to cure. That would defeat the whole drugstore convenience factor for me. Does anyone know for sure?

2 Likes

LA Colors metallic silver is gorgeous. Only 2 thin coats for full opacity.

LA Colors, if you’re stateside. Good shimmers for the price, and they’re easier to find in the US than elsewhere.

Sinful Colors is worth grabbing too, but only if you spot it. They’ve been harder to track down lately.

Hybrid non-UV gels. Worth looking into if you haven’t tried them yet. Sally and Essie both make versions (no lamp needed). They hold up well.

Someone asked about Essence. The glitters are the star. I did a chunky silver one over a navy creme and people kept asking if I got them done.

Getting it off is a whole afternoon of scrubbing, though. Then I started putting a peel-off base coat underneath, and now the glitter lifts off in one piece.

The bottles are smaller than Sally Hansen or Revlon. A couple of mine went thick and gloopy around the halfway point. A few drops of actual polish thinner brought mine right back, not remover, since that ruins the formula.

1 Like