Best Nail Polish Brands to Use Yourself?

I need some honest opinions on nail polish brands right now. I know we have the thread on the professional brands, but I’m looking for just the best polish brands in general.

I’ve been rotating between OPI and Essie, along with CND Vinylux, but curious what everyone else swears by for wear time and pigment. Any newer indie brands worth adding to my collection, or should I stick with the classics? Spill the tea!

21 Likes

Fiji. Since you already use Essie, go with that. It’s a soft, milky pastel pink, and it levels out way better than most pale shades I’ve tried, so I can do thin coats without getting obvious streaks. Two coats give you full coverage and look clean. One coat is softer and more natural-looking. It dries pretty fast, and with a base and top coat, it lasts close to two weeks on me. Good pick for an easy everyday color. Just don’t put it on too thick because the pigment builds up fast.

4 Likes

The classic OPI Nail Lacquer might be what you’re looking for. It wears well and the colors work for everyday. On my natural nails I get about 12-14 days before it chips. When it does chip, it’s usually a small spot on the edge, mostly after a lot of scrubbing or housework.

4 Likes

This Sally Hansen is worth having around. It’s a semi-sheer pale pink nude. One coat looks clean and glossy, and two even it out without going chalky. It dries a lot faster than my Essies, so it’s what I grab when I’m in a hurry and I think it’s easier to work with.

2 Likes

OPI and Essie are still hard to beat for cream finishes. CND Vinylux wears well if you use its matching top coat.

Orly is another solid classic. The bottles and brushes are easy to handle and most shades are opaque in two coats.

For indies, ilnp is the easiest place to start if you want consistent formulas and good wear, especially the holos and multichromes. Mooncat has striking colors, but some of the formulas run thick, so try one or two shades before placing a big order off swatches.

What helped me most was matching my routine to my nails: wiping off surface oil, wrapping the free edge, keeping coats thin, and picking a base coat that suits how flexible or rigid your nails are. With that prep, ilnp, Orly and OPI all wear about the same on me.

Prep and top coat do most of the work for wear time. I’ve had a cheap Sinful Colors shade last a full week with a good base and a glossy top.

Once you’re at the OPI/Essie level, fixing your routine will get you more days than switching brands will.

I use Zoya the most. The formula is a little thinner than OPI so it’s easy to control, and they run sales where you can stock up for the price of one salon visit. Cremes and metallics are the best ones.

For newer stuff, Mooncat and Holo Taco are the two I’d add. Mooncat’s shimmers and crellies are pretty and the brush is good. Holo Taco I mostly buy for the toppers and the top coat. Their quick-dry glossy one replaced Seche Vite since it doesn’t shrink at the tips.

Drugstore vote: Sally Hansen Insta-Dri, if you do your nails at 11pm and need them dry before bed. Wear isn’t as long as the others but it’s close, and the bottles are a few bucks.

3 Likes

I’ve stopped treating formula as something a brand either has or doesn’t. OPI’s reds are flawless. Some of their pastels are streaky. Essie’s sheer pinks and dark creams might as well come from two different companies.

Since you already have the big three covered, look at the longwear lines inside those brands. Essie Gel Couture is a different formula from regular Essie, thicker and more self-leveling, and with its own top coat I get a solid five or six days without a lamp. Sally Hansen Miracle Gel is the drugstore version of the same idea. It holds up nearly as well for a third of the price.

On pigment, China Glaze is worth a look. It’s an older salon brand, but the creams and brights are dense and the bottles cost less than OPI. The formula runs thick, so keep some thinner around.

One caution on indies. A lot of them sell in small batches, so if you fall in love with a shade it may be gone in six months.

If you do want indies, Holo Taco is where I’d start for everyday use. Their one-coat creams are one coat. Mooncat is beautiful and their flakies and shimmers are hard to match, but the price is closer to a department store brand.

1 Like

If wear time is the main goal, try Dazzle Dry before buying another regular polish. It air-dries fast with no lamp, and I get noticeably longer wear from it than from normal polish. It is expensive, and you need the full system with thin coats.

Holo Taco has good pigment and fun finishes. Their creams and metallics are often close to opaque in one coat.

KBShimmer is another one I like, mostly reflective glitters and thermals. The formulas are easier to work with.

Buy indie for finishes you can’t get from the big brands. Wear time varies a ton from brand to brand, so don’t count on it being better.

Also watch out for swatch photos shot under intense lighting. Reflective and magnetic shades look a lot more muted in normal indoor light than they do in those pics.

1 Like

The Dazzle Dry thin coats thing is real, since every time I got impatient and went thick it peeled within two days.

Yeah, the China Glaze thickness is real, I keep a little bottle of thinner right next to mine and it’s been fine for years.

The swatch lighting warning is real, since my last magnetic polish looked like a galaxy online and wet asphalt under my kitchen lights.

Miracle Gel doesn’t hold up as well for me, and around here it’s only a few dollars cheaper. I get tip wear by day three, while Gel Couture usually makes it to day six. The Miracle Gel top coat also clouds faster over pale colors.

Backing you up on the Holo Taco creams. The few I own are almost one-coaters. Metallics are pretty too, but I have to watch for brushstrokes and let the first coat settle before adding more.

For thermals I use KBShimmer too. The shift gets weaker as your nails grow out. The color change depends on the temperature difference along the nail, so they look most dramatic in the first few days after a fresh mani.

6 Likes

This was helpful, especially the tip about letting the first coat settle before adding the second. Which KBShimmer thermal has given you the best color shift and wear time? Trying to decide which one to pick up first.

Butter London’s range is great if you want something a little more upscale but don’t want to go full indie. Orly’s solid too and easier to find. Deborah Lippmann is pricey, but the formulas are good.

The Gel Couture top coat alone makes a difference even over other polishes, and the full system gets me about five days unless I’m hard on my hands. No lamp.

Orly Bonder is the only base coat that works for me.

Prep matters too. Push back your cuticles and buff the nails before washing off the oil with soap.

Also, the more often you polish your nails, the longer manis tend to stay on since the nail surface gets more porous over time.

Mainstream is your Zoya and Color Club, sitting alongside Essie and Sally Hansen. Then you’ve got boutique brands like ILNP and Mooncat that do more specialty finishes, along with Cirque Colors.

Past that are the indies like KB Shimmer and Glisten & Glow, which are usually smaller operations with unique formulas, along with Rogue Lacquer.

If you want to try indie without spending a lot, ILNP might be worth a look. Decent formula and tons of colors with good wear time (for me, anyway).

These are just the ones that work for me, not necessarily the best.

My current rotation, since you asked about indies: Polished for Days, Emily de Molly, Mooncat, and Cadillacquer. Lately I’ve also been into some smaller ones like Chamaeleon, Fauve, Lurid Lacquer and Night Owl.